Noni Madueke Faces Criticism After Miss Despite Win

Anthony Gordon and Ollie Watkins may have wrapped up a routine win, but the post‑match conversation belonged to Noni Madueke – and not for the reasons he would have hoped.

A glaring first-half miss, followed by a relaxed reaction at full-time, lit up social media. The scoreline flattered the winger’s evening; the scrutiny did not.

On X, the criticism came in hard. “Hopefully that’s the last we see of him this World Cup. Does ANYONE think he should be there?” wrote @cooksbits, capturing the impatience of a fanbase already picking its World Cup XI in their heads.

Another user, @marklamb2002, took aim at Madueke’s demeanour as much as the miss itself: “Laughing and smiling about it send him back and get foden here such a washed player.” The message was clear – this audience wanted ruthlessness, not levity.

The selection debate grew louder. “The only reason why he’s in that squad is because he’s part of a premier league winning team. He contributed about 1 goal and 2 assists btw. I’d take out of form Palmer or Bowen over him without thinking twice,” argued @click00001, turning a single chance into a referendum on his entire inclusion.

Madueke did not hide from the moment. He walked through it.

“I should have scored one,” he admitted after the final whistle. “We definitely had a few chances, Morgz [Morgan Rogers] I think. But it will come. Better to miss them now than when the tournament starts."

He went further, dissecting the decision in the box that left fans exasperated. “I should’ve probably gone with my right foot. Obviously, it was happening quick. I should’ve scored it, but when the tournament comes, I will score them.”

The numbers on the scoreboard offered comfort. The reaction online did not. For Madueke, the next time the ball drops to him in front of goal, it will carry more than just the weight of a chance – it will carry the noise of a fanbase already demanding proof that he belongs on the plane.