Top 10 Premier League Penalty Takers: A Ranked Overview

The Premier League has showcased some remarkable penalty takers, known for their calmness and precision under pressure. Alan Shearer leads with 56 penalties scored, while Yaya Touré stands out with a flawless record. Other notable names include Matt Le Tissier and Harry Kane, famous for their consistency. New talents such as Cole Palmer and Erling Haaland are carrying forward this legacy. These players have combined skill, nerve, and accuracy to become some of the greatest penalty scorers in Premier League history.

Penalty kicks remain one of football’s most dependable scoring methods. Many forwards have relied on their composure and technique from the spot since the league began. The challenge of converting penalties is immense, requiring precision, intelligence, and nerves of steel. Players like English star Harry Kane regularly deliver under pressure during Golden Boot pursuits. But who truly ranks among the best penalty takers in Premier League history?

We've put together a list of the top 10 penalty takers based on their records, showcasing those who have impressed by scoring crucial goals, often deciding matches with their spot-kick prowess.

Top 10 Premier League Penalty Scorers

• Rank: 10Player: Bukayo SakaClubs: ArsenalYears Active: 2019–PresentPenalties Scored: 12
• Rank: 9Player: James BeattieClubs: Southampton, Everton, Sheffield United, Stoke CityYears Active: 1998–2010Penalties Scored: 16
• Rank: 8Player: Callum WilsonClubs: Bournemouth, Newcastle UnitedYears Active: 2014–PresentPenalties Scored: 16
• Rank: 7Player: Erling HaalandClubs: Manchester CityYears Active: 2022–PresentPenalties Scored: 20
• Rank: 6Player: Danny MurphyClubs: Liverpool, Charlton, Tottenham, FulhamYears Active: 1997–2013Penalties Scored: 18
• Rank: 5Player: Harry KaneClubs: Tottenham HotspurYears Active: 2012–2023Penalties Scored: 33
• Rank: 4Player: Cole PalmerClubs: Manchester City, ChelseaYears Active: 2021–PresentPenalties Scored: 18
• Rank: 3Player: Matt Le TissierClubs: SouthamptonYears Active: 1992–2002Penalties Scored: 25
• Rank: 2Player: Yaya TouréClubs: Manchester CityYears Active: 2010–2018Penalties Scored: 11
• Rank: 1Player: Alan ShearerClubs: Blackburn Rovers, Newcastle UnitedYears Active: 1992–2006Penalties Scored: 56

Insights into the Top Penalty Specialists

After missing a penalty in the UEFA Euro 2020 final, Bukayo Saka rebounded to become one of Arsenal's most trusted penalty takers. He boasts an impressive 92% conversion rate, scoring 12 out of 13 attempts. With 223 Premier League appearances and 59 goals, his calmness in front of goal is evident.

James Beattie stood out as a deadly penalty scorer across multiple clubs including Southampton and Everton. He converted 16 penalties from 17 attempts during his Premier League career spanning 270 appearances, maintaining a 94% success rate.

Known for his composure, Callum Wilson scored 16 penalties at a 94% rate, representing Bournemouth, Newcastle, and West Ham over 267 appearances. His reliable penalty record remains a highlight of his career.

Erling Haaland quickly gained a reputation for clinical finishing, scoring 20 penalties out of 23 attempts for Manchester City, an 87% conversion rate. His ability to perform under pressure marks him as one of the top current strikers.

Danny Murphy earned respect for his precise penalty taking, scoring 18 penalties with a 95% success rate. Over 417 Premier League appearances for clubs like Liverpool and Fulham, he missed just once, which came against Manchester City but did not affect the final outcome.

Harry Kane converted 33 penalties from 37 attempts for Tottenham Hotspur, holding an 89% success rate. Now at Bayern Munich, his ability to consistently score from the spot made him one of the Premier League's most feared penalty takers.

Cole Palmer maintained a near-perfect penalty record with 18 goals from 19 attempts playing for Manchester City and Chelsea. His coolness in front of goal continues to impress despite a recent miss against Leicester City.

The Southampton legend, Matt Le Tissier, was renowned for his penalty skills, converting 24 out of 25 attempts. Nicknamed “Le God,” he scored 101 goals in 270 Premier League appearances, missing only once in a game against Nottingham Forest.

Yaya Touré holds the unique distinction of a perfect penalty record in the Premier League, scoring all 11 penalties he took while at Manchester City. His composed style and skill made him a formidable midfielder and spot-kick specialist.

Alan Shearer tops the list with 56 penalty goals, the highest in Premier League history. Despite missing 10 or more penalties, his overall contribution of 260 goals in 441 appearances for Blackburn and Newcastle cements his legacy as a penalty expert and the league's all-time top scorer.

Frequently Asked Questions

• Who is the Premier League's greatest penalty taker?Alan Shearer leads the rankings as the top penalty scorer.
• Is Erling Haaland among the top 10 Premier League penalty takers?Yes, Haaland ranks 7th on the list.
• Who are the top three Premier League penalty takers?They are Alan Shearer, Yaya Touré, and Matt Le Tissier.
• Where does Erling Haaland stand among the greatest Premier League penalty takers?He is ranked 7th overall.